On a mobile device? Try our mobile site, optimized for faster browsing.

Yelp New York

New York Sandwiches

Russ & Daughters

1. Russ & Daughters

4.5 star rating
47 reviews

Category: Ethnic Food, Seafood Markets, Caterers

The beautiful fruit in the window called my name and then the stink of smoked fish b-slapped me right across the face.  I tried to buy some delicious looking chocolate-dipped macaroons yesterday or possibly some gorgeous chocolates & dried apricots, but the smell of herring and cured salmon was so overwhelming that I couldn't get past it.  The smell encompassed everything; it seemed like my…

Sandwiches in New York By Borough

Best New York Sandwiches By Feature

Related Sandwiches Searches

Great Bread

4.5 star rating 17 reviews

1. Panera Bread

Neighborhood: New Jersey/Hoboken

user photo

to be that way. they remind me of a subway with more bread than filling. but i give the nod to panera for their bread on steroids and their array of desserts. the salads are good but once again...

4.5 star rating 85 reviews

2. Amy's Bread

Neighborhood: Manhattan/Hell's Kitchen

user photo

Hands down the best cupcakes in Manhattan. Great traditional breads of a wide variety. Always friendly staff. Whether it's dessert, fresh bread, or a sandwich Amy's has got you covered. Easy to get...

4.5 star rating 29 reviews

3. Bite

Neighborhood: Manhattan/Greenwich Village

user photo

Surprisingly good sandwiches...I had the Middle Eastern with mushrooms.  I say surprisingly since it didn't look that great but the flavor was great.  High bread-to-filling ratio.  I'd say two-thirds...

4.5 star rating 41 reviews

4. Bite

Neighborhood: Manhattan/East Village

user photo

simple and small.  We shared a Hummus plate (sauteed mushrooms) and split a prosciutto & mozzarella Panini.  The wine list looked great, but we each had a beer instead, which also had a decent...

4.5 star rating 15 reviews

5. City Sub

Neighborhood: Brooklyn/Park Slope

user photo

This place has the best sub I've had in New York.  The bread is great and the toppings are fresh but the true secret is how thin they slice their meat.  Delicious....

More Great Bread in Sandwiches »

Quality Meats

4.5 star rating 15 reviews

1. City Sub

Neighborhood: Brooklyn/Park Slope

user photo

Delicious subs. I had the Ham, Salami, and Provolone. High quality ingredients with fresh sliced meat make all the difference. It's worth coming, but I had to wait 20ish minutes so watch out....

4 star rating 192 reviews

2. Carnegie…

Neighborhood: Manhattan/Theater District

user photo

of average-quality meat between 2 small pieces of bread. I used Russian Dressing (similar to Thousand Island) and the spicy mustard on the table to add some flavor, but the sandwich was still nothing...

4.5 star rating 17 reviews

3. Panera Bread

Neighborhood: New Jersey/Hoboken

user photo

appetites complain sometimes that there isn't enough meat in their sandwiches, I'm more content with quality than quantity. I have loved nearly everything I've had here and come back for repeat visits...

4.5 star rating 13 reviews

4. Sunny and Annie's

Neighborhood: Manhattan/East Village

user photo

One of the neighborhood's best kept secrets.  This bodega is 24 hours, and has an array of quality deli meats at a low price.  The food is always quality, and they're always polite.  They deliver (10...

4 star rating 37 reviews

5. Carl's Steaks

Neighborhood: Manhattan/Murray Hill

user photo

little of it.. perhaps it was cooked too long but the quality and tastelessness of the meat did not impress.  With the huge roll enveloping what very little there was, it was underwhelming.. hence...

More Quality Meats in Sandwiches »